Simbarashe Kundizeza, a Zimbabwean author, has been cleared of using artificial intelligence to write his short story, “The Blue Fighter,” after a month-long investigation by the prestigious Caine prize for African writers. The prize concluded the story was “human-written.” “The Blue Fighter,” which explores the struggles of a family after the father’s investment in fish tanks, was announced as the winner of the £10,000 prize on October 6. Five days later, an article in The Atlantic, authored by Vauhini Vara, raised concerns about the potential use of AI in the story. Vara noted that AI-detection software, Pangram (which itself utilizes AI), suggested the story was largely artificially generated. Ellah Wakatama, chair of the Caine prize, stated in a release that their investigation “found clear evidence” the story was human-written and expressed anticipation for awarding and celebrating Kundizeza before the year’s end. She emphasized the prize’s commitment to a “human-centered” approach during the investigation, adding that it was their duty to carefully and fairly address the concerns raised. The review process, according to Wakatama, involved interviews with the author, the 2026 judging panel, and The Shallow Tales Review, where the story was initially published. It also incorporated independent metadata analysis of drafts by Kundizeza. Kundizeza, who previously denied using generative AI in the writing process, expressed relief at the dismissal of the allegations. “It was not necessary in the first place,” he stated, “I am happy to put all this behind me and continue with my writing journey.” Vara’s article sparked considerable online backlash, with many users expressing concern about accusations of AI use disproportionately targeting Black writers, especially those of African descent.
